How to Calculate Short-Term Rental ROI
The six numbers that decide whether a short-term rental works, with every formula shown and a full worked example on a $425K Nashville home.
By Barron HansenPublished Updated 12 min read
Why STR ROI Is Harder Than Long-Term Rental ROI
For a long-term rental, ROI is close to simple arithmetic: annual rent minus mortgage, taxes, insurance and maintenance, divided by the cash you put in.
A short-term rental is a small hospitality business. The rate changes every night, a large share of nights stay empty, and every stay brings a cleaning bill and a platform fee. Since late 2025 most Airbnb hosts pay a single 15.5% host-only fee instead of the old 3% split fee, which by itself moves a typical deal's NOI by about 12% of gross revenue.
The most common mistake is "nightly rate times 30 times 12". A $185 rate becomes $66,600 a year on paper. Book 62% of nights, give up 15.5% to Airbnb, pay $7,000 for cleaning and another $15,000 for everything else, and before the mortgage you are left with well under half of that number.
The Six Core STR Metrics
1. Gross Annual Revenue
$189 ADR at 62% occupancy: $189 × 0.62 × 365 = $42,771. The ADR should be the average you actually collect, after discounts, not your listed weekend price.
2. Net Operating Income (NOI)
Net operating income is revenue minus every operating cost, before the mortgage. It is the financing-neutral measure of what the property produces.
3. Cash-on-Cash Return
Cash-on-cash return is the cash you get back each year as a share of the cash you put in.
Total cash invested includes the down payment, closing costs and furnishing and setup. The cash-on-cash calculator does this in one step.
4. Cap Rate
Cap rate is the return the property would produce if you paid cash. It lets you compare properties regardless of how they are financed.
5. Break-Even Occupancy
Break-even occupancy is the share of nights you must book to cover every cost including the mortgage. Percentage-based costs (the Airbnb fee, a manager's cut) shrink each booked night, so they go in the denominator.
6. DSCR
Debt service coverage ratio compares income to the loan payment. Two versions matter. Most DSCR lenders use gross (or projected) rent divided by the full monthly payment including taxes, insurance and HOA (PITIA). An investor's version uses NOI divided by debt service, which tells you whether the property actually pays for itself.
Calculate all six metrics at once
Enter a property and see revenue, NOI, cash-on-cash, cap rate, break-even and DSCR update together.
Worked Example: $425,000 in Nashville
A single-family home priced near the Nashville market's numbers in our data. One caution first: Nashville does not issue new non-owner-occupied STR permits in most residential zones, so check the parcel on Metro Codes before treating any Nashville house as an investor STR. See the Nashville market page for the current figures.
The 7.25% rate is an assumption for an investment property, which typically prices above the owner-occupied average in Freddie Mac's weekly survey. Use a real quote for your own numbers.
Step 1: Gross revenue
Step 2: Operating expenses
Step 3: NOI
Step 4: Cash flow
The property loses about $1,230 a month after the mortgage, before counting the owner's time.
Step 5: Cash-on-cash return
Cash invested: $85,000 down + $5,500 closing + $12,000 furnishing and setup = $102,500.
Step 6: Cap rate
Step 7: Break-even occupancy
This treats cleaning as fixed; in reality it falls when bookings fall, so the true break-even is a few points lower. It is still far above the 62% this listing is projected to achieve. The break-even occupancy calculator lets you vary each input.
Step 8: DSCR, two ways
Lender method: $3,564 monthly gross rent ÷ $2,945 PITIA (payment plus about $425 tax and $200 insurance) = 1.21, which many DSCR lenders would approve. Investor method: $13,066 NOI ÷ $27,840 debt service = 0.47. A lender's yes does not mean the deal works. Test both in the DSCR calculator.
Verdict: this deal does not work at 20% down. It needs a lower price, a higher ADR, much better occupancy or a lower rate. For comparison, the same listing on Airbnb's older 3% split fee would pay $1,283 in fees, show $18,413 of NOI and lose $9,427 a year. Still negative, but the fee setting alone is a $5,347 swing, which is why the platform fee calculator asks which structure you are on.
Common Mistakes That Inflate STR Projections
Using peak occupancy instead of the annual average
"Potential revenue" figures often reflect peak months or top-performing listings. Underwrite to the annual average of true comparables. For reference, the median across the 55 markets in our dataset is about 57% occupancy at a $212 ADR.
Modeling the old 3% Airbnb fee
Airbnb's help center says it is moving all home hosts to a single host-only fee, 15.5% for most hosts, and it is already mandatory for hosts using property management software. The 3% split fee is being phased out. On $42,000 of bookings the difference is about $5,200 a year. Vrbo moves to a flat 12% commission (payment processing included) from October 29, 2026, replacing the earlier 5% commission plus about 3% processing.
Ignoring cleaning and restocking
At $75 to $150 a turnover and 90 or more stays a year, cleaning alone runs $7,000 to $13,000. Guest cleaning fees offset part of it, but only if you charge them and count them.
Underestimating maintenance
Constant turnover wears a house faster than a family does. Budget at least 1% of the price a year and consider 1.5% to 2% for high-turnover properties: $6,375 to $8,500 on a $425,000 home.
Not modeling slow months
A 62% annual average can hide a 40% January. In seasonal markets, model month by month and hold enough cash to carry the mortgage through the slow stretch.
STR ROI vs Stock Market Returns
A broad stock index fund asks nothing of your time. A short-term rental is leveraged and labor-intensive. Leverage amplifies appreciation (a 5% rise on a $500,000 house financed with $100,000 down is a 25% gain on equity) and amplifies losses the same way, and a negative-cash-flow rental needs new money every month.
Count your time. Ten hours a month at $75 an hour is $9,000 a year of work the stock portfolio never asks for. If the rental only beats the index once you value that time at zero, it is a job, not an investment.
How to Improve Your STR ROI
Price dynamically
Pricing tools such as PriceLabs and Wheelhouse adjust nightly rates for demand, events and day of week. Treat vendor claims of revenue lift as marketing until you see them in your own calendar; the pricing calculator shows what a given ADR change does to annual revenue.
Control management cost
Full-service managers charge 20% to 35% of revenue. Self-management costs software plus your time. Our property management guide compares the two honestly.
Buy the right market
Market choice outweighs almost any operating tactic. In our data, Sedona runs about $398 ADR at 71% occupancy, while many urban markets run under $200. Compare markets on revenue relative to price (gross yield), not revenue alone; Pigeon Forge earns far less per listing than Sedona but costs far less to buy. The best markets guide ranks all 55.
Run your own numbers
Test a real deal in the free calculator
Plug in the price, nightly rate and occupancy for a property you are looking at. You will see cash flow, cap rate, cash-on-cash return and break-even occupancy, with every assumption visible and editable.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
- Airbnb Help Center: Airbnb service fees. Host-only (single) fee of 15.5% for most hosts; split fee being phased out
- Vrbo Help: How is the booking fee calculated?. Flat 12% commission that includes payment processing
- Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey (PMMS). Weekly average 30-year fixed rate for owner-occupied loans
- Metro Nashville Codes: Short Term Rental Property permits