Is Airbnb More Profitable Than Renting Long-Term?
Short-term and long-term rental compared on the same house, with current Airbnb fees, the time cost of hosting and the risks that only show up later.
By Barron HansenPublished Updated 10 min read
The Core Tradeoff: More Revenue, Much More Work
A short-term rental usually brings in more gross revenue than a lease on the same house. It also costs more to run, takes far more of your time, and depends on local rules that can change. Neither strategy is better everywhere. The answer depends on the market, the house, the rules and how many hours you want to spend.
Same House, Both Ways
A three-bedroom, $425,000 home in Nashville, financed with 20% down. STR figures use $189 ADR and 62% occupancy on Airbnb's 15.5% host-only fee. The lease is $2,000 a month with a 10% manager.
The STR grosses 78% more but nets only $2,391 more NOI, and that is before valuing the 8 to 15 hours a month the owner spends hosting, while the lease already pays a manager. Both lose money at this price and leverage. On Airbnb's older 3% split fee the STR's NOI advantage would be about $7,700, which is why the current fee matters so much to this comparison.
Nashville also illustrates the regulatory point: the city does not issue new non-owner-occupied STR permits in most residential zones, so for many houses the lease column is the only legal one. Check the Nashville market page and Metro Codes before you buy.
Run the comparison on your property
Enter your own numbers and see STR and LTR side by side.
The Hidden Costs of Short-Term Rentals
Cleaning and turnover: $75 to $150 a turnover, 80 to 120 checkouts a year, so $6,000 to $18,000.
Platform fees: 15.5% for most Airbnb hosts, 12% on Vrbo from October 29, 2026. A lease has no equivalent.
Supplies: toiletries, paper goods, coffee and small replacements, $800 to $1,500 a year.
Insurance: a dedicated STR policy, often $1,500 to $3,500 a year versus roughly $800 to $1,500 for a landlord policy.
Your time: 6 to 12 hours a month even when organized. At $50 to $100 an hour that is $3,600 to $14,400 a year that never appears on a statement. A manager instead costs 20% to 35% of revenue; the management fee calculator compares the two.
The Hidden Costs of Long-Term Rentals
Turnover between tenants: paint, carpet cleaning and repairs plus two to six weeks vacant. On a $2,000 lease, one month vacant and $2,500 of turnover work cuts the year's income by about 19%.
Tenant damage can exceed the deposit, even with careful screening.
Eviction: depending on the state, removing a nonpaying tenant can take months and thousands in legal costs. A guest simply checks out.
Risk Comparison
Regulation is the risk that can end an STR outright. New York City's Local Law 18 requires registration and a host present for stays under 30 days, which ended most whole-unit investor listings. New Orleans limits STRs in residential areas. Always check the rules, and how stable they are, before buying. Our New York and New Orleans market pages summarize them.
Seasonality: a beach house can run 80% in summer and 25% in winter, while the mortgage stays the same. Hold reserves for the slow months.
Platform dependency: Airbnb's 2025 fee change shows how one policy update can move NOI by thousands. Listing on more than one channel helps but does not remove the risk.
Lease vacancy: lower in size, but in a soft market a unit can sit for two or three months between tenants.
When STR Clearly Wins
Destination markets with stable rules where STR revenue is several times a lease, such as the Smoky Mountains (Gatlinburg, Pigeon Forge) or Gulf beach towns like Destin.
Distinctive properties (A-frames, lakefront cabins, treehouses) whose nightly appeal a lease cannot capture.
Owners who want to host and treat it as a business: quick replies, high standards, steady reviews.
Owner-occupied setups in cities that only permit STRs in your primary residence. If you plan to live in one unit and rent another, the house hack calculator models it. Note that FHA-financed homes cannot be rented for stays under 30 days.
When LTR Clearly Wins
Restricted markets where non-owner-occupied permits are capped, frozen or banned.
Investors who want passive income. A managed lease takes an hour or two a month; a self-managed STR takes 8 to 15.
High-rent cities where leases are already strong and STR rules are strict.
Ordinary houses in non-tourist areas without a clear reason for someone to book a night there.
Mid-Term and Hybrid Strategies
Furnished stays of 30 nights or more sit between the two. Many city STR ordinances do not apply at 30+ nights, turnover is far lower, and rents are usually above an unfurnished lease. Some owners run short stays in peak season and 30+ night stays in the off-season, which works best in college towns and strongly seasonal markets.
Mid-term stays also change the tax picture: they generally keep the 27.5-year depreciation schedule and passive treatment, while short stays usually mean 39 years and possible non-passive treatment. The Airbnb tax guide explains both.
Check your target market
Compare ADR, occupancy and revenue estimates across our 55 markets.
Making the Decision
1. What do the rules allow at this address? A deal that needs a permit you cannot get is not a deal.
2. Compare NOI, not gross. Use current fees (15.5% Airbnb, 12% Vrbo) and real cleaning costs. If the STR's NOI advantage is small, the extra work and risk are probably not worth it.
3. How many hours can you give it? Self-managed STR is 8 to 15 hours a month. Professional management costs 20% to 35% of revenue. Model both.
4. What is the STR break-even occupancy? If it sits within 10 points of the market average, one weak year turns the deal negative.
5. What is the exit? A lease-ready house sells to investors and owner-occupants; a permit-dependent STR sells mostly to investors, and only while the permit transfers.
Run your own numbers
Test a real deal in the free calculator
Plug in the price, nightly rate and occupancy for a property you are looking at. You will see cash flow, cap rate, cash-on-cash return and break-even occupancy, with every assumption visible and editable.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
- Airbnb Help Center: Airbnb service fees. Host-only (single) fee of 15.5% for most hosts; split fee being phased out
- Metro Nashville Codes: Short Term Rental Property permits
- NYC Office of Special Enforcement: Short-term rental registration (Local Law 18)
- City of New Orleans: Short Term Rentals
- IRS Publication 527, Residential Rental Property. Personal-use days, the 14-day / 10% rule, rental expense allocation